• 10 June, 2023
Geopolitics & National Security
MENU

Peaceful Pakistan: A Utopian Vision?

Mudasir Dar Thu, 18 May 2023   |  Reading Time: 4 minutes

Pakistan’s recurring political crises can be traced back to its inability to fortify democratic institutions and build a robust state-society relationship since its independence. The present political conundrum is the latest outburst of this crisis that commenced in 2022. The opposition parties banded together to present a no-confidence motion against Imran Khan’s government in the National Assembly.

This action had political ramifications throughout the nation, leading to a chain of crises that impacted governance at both the national and provincial levels. The crises did not stop in Islamabad; the resignation of Punjab Chief Minister Usman Buzdar on the imperative of Prime Minister Imran Khan in favor of PTI’s ally Pervaiz Elahi supplemented the apprehension that political chaos is not far from exacerbation. Soon, the Chief Minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Mahmood Khan, faced a no-confidence motion from the opposition parties in the provincial assembly. Similarly, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) submitted a motion of no-confidence against their own Administered Kashmir prime minister adding another leaf to the complexity.

On May 9, 2023, Imran Khan was taken into custody by the police at the Islamabad High Court. The arrest of Imran resulted in a widespread demonstration by his followers across the country. According to reports, supporters of the PTI engaged in violent behavior as a means of protesting against the arrest. The country has implemented a ban on various social media platforms, such as Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Khan’s arrest was carried out by NAB officials, specifically acting upon the  Al-Qadir Trust case. Since being removed from office in April of last year, Khan has been confronted with a series of legal challenges and is currently dealing with a significant number of legal cases, totaling over 140, which are related to various serious offenses such as terrorism, blasphemy, murder, violence, and incitement to violence.

Interconnected Challenge of Economic Collapse and Extremism

The current impasse has associated causes, which makes it imperative to address those in the first place and then move on to correct the constitutional crises. These associated factors are economic collapse, internal security, and extremism. The economic crisis that Pakistan is currently facing arises due to a pattern of factors ranging from financial mismanagement, political instability, crony capitalism, corrupt political practices, and the severe floods that occurred in 2022. These factors have collectively contributed to the country’s economic instability and brought it to the brink of collapse. The reliance on IMF bailouts and debt concessions from partners like China, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE only aggravates and hurts its economic growth, which is highly dependent on internal stability. For internal stability, Pakistan needs to teach its people civic sense, and as long as the military establishment controls the political order, it is impossible to achieve this goal.

An unstable Pakistan is a grave concern for regional stability given the sense of alienation in the regions of Khyber Pakhtun and Balochistan, which has given rise to separatism and extremism, making Pakistan a breeding ground for transnational extremism. Therefore, a democratic Pakistan would have been a win-win situation for South Asia and India in particular. A democratic Pakistan would not have let its soil be used to fetch cross-border extremism and separatism. It would have respect for human rights, procedural justice, and integrity, which indicates that there are legitimacy crises deeply entrenched in the military establishment as well as mannequin political leadership. The reliance on transnational extremism, particularly in Kashmir, has so far enabled the establishment to satisfy this deficiency. Therefore, it is high time for Kashmiris to realize the fault lines that lie beneath the surface and not rely on Pakistani rhetoric of freedom and separatism. A state that suffers from external political meddling cannot claim to be a beacon of freedom for others.

Pakistan should not be compared with republics, democracies, and sovereignties in the region and beyond, making it difficult to comprehend. In reality, Pakistani politics has a novel and straightforward format. It’s undeniable that the Army is the only strong institution that believes it can keep the nation together in the face of the gravest of difficulties, and that it’s more than just a political party in its own right. Its preeminence may be attributed to three main factors: keeping the corrupt political structure afloat, exploiting the Kashmir problem for legitimacy, and skillfully administering the project of social engineering in disturbed regions. In other words, it makes no difference how many people support Imran Khan or Shahbaz Sharif in the election, how many people show up to rallies for Khan or Sharif, or how many people vote. It has a powerful nuclear arsenal but a feeble economy, making it very reliant on external economic support from the United States and China.

Unstable Political Landscape – Threat to Regional Stability

When it comes to the necessity of maintaining good relations with the United States, the Army knows more than any political party or leader. Thus, Imran Khan committed political suicide when, on February 24, 2022, he  a visited Moscow. According to IK, despite being the Army’s sweetheart in 2018, the United States wants to replace Khan as Prime Minister and has expressed this wish via a minor employee at the State Department named Donald Lu. His temper outbursts, bombastic speeches, and social media clout won’t help him regain power. There is a strong possibility of barring him from running in the National Assembly elections, and his party is also likely to lose several members through defection to the opposition—encouraged by the Army at the US’s behest. The fact that he publicly accused actual generals sealed his fate. If he avoids the destiny of leaders like ZA Bhutto, he may consider himself lucky. Amidst the ongoing political turmoil in Pakistan, it is important to note the role of Imran Khan and the extent to which he has gone  to gain power. He has done everything by putting the country at stake and being willing to go to any extent to achieve his political ambitions. His actions and decisions have contributed to the current state of crisis in the nation. It’s uninformed and useless for Indian TV stations to debate whether PTI or PML-N has a better chance of regaining power.

To conclude, an unstable Pakistan is dangerous for India and the region. A stable Pakistan is a requirement for peace in the subcontinent. For India a peaceful, vibrant, and democratic neighbour which respects  human dignity and having the understanding that in a peaceful environment lies prosperity and growth will always be the best scenario plausible

 


Author
Mudasir Dar is a social and peace activist based in South Kashmir. He is a Rashtrapati Award recipient in world scouting and has contributed to many local and national publications on a diverse range of topics, including national security, politics, governance, peace, and conflict.

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not reflect the views of Chanakya Forum. All information provided in this article including timeliness, completeness, accuracy, suitability or validity of information referenced therein, is the sole responsibility of the author. www.chanakyaforum.com does not assume any responsibility for the same.


Chanakya Forum is now on . Click here to join our channel (@ChanakyaForum) and stay updated with the latest headlines and articles.

Important

We work round the clock to bring you the finest articles and updates from around the world. There is a team that works tirelessly to ensure that you have a seamless reading experience. But all this costs money. Please support us so that we keep doing what we do best. Happy Reading

Support Us
Or
9289230333
Or

POST COMMENTS (1)

Kalidan Singh

Jun 03, 2023
Whether peace can come to Pakistan or not, is a problem that I wish we in India would no longer regard as a matter of concern. Mostly because 'concern' about Pakistan leads us to extremely foolish and dangerous notions of 'people to people exchange,' 'trade' and some sort of a diplomatic relationship with them. It leads us to think we understand the complexity of the problem of Pakistan, of the Pakistan-India relationship; worse it, it leads us to dangerous wishful thinking about what we can do. It is true that between 1947 and 2014, the Indian governments focused entirely on seeking the goodwill of Pakistanis and their local representatives, and sought their validation (particularly in the ways we defined our own history and taught it in schools). Pakistan devoted their entire effort to creating a population with adherence to dangerous myths of being a martial race of Central Asians, about their racial and religious superiority, and their absolute hatred of India based on the claim that Muslims were in peril within our borders. Be that what it may. Current Pakistani rhetoric is entirely India focused; and I fear our entire rhetoric is one of hubris and Pakistan focused. Pakistani brass and media are constantly draw comparisons: (how dare) India is doing these things and we are not (this is unfair). There is zero interest among the likes of Qamar Cheema for instance to take responsibility for the terrorism they sponsor; all he demands is apology from Indian talking heads about the accomplishments and problems of India. We need to stop indulging this. We cannot talk to a country that proclaims terrorism as a key ingredient of foreign policy, and then expects us to help them out (so they can stab us again). The fact that our own people indulge in the fantasy and imagine good relations with Pakistan - bothers me the most. Pakistan can be peaceful or not, economically developing or not - I want all of India to erect a big conceptual wall and stop communicating in any way that aims to build peace (we can focus on transactions). The other thing we can do is encourage the apologists of Pakistan who live in India, and people who fly the Pakistani flag in India, to leave for Pakistan at taxpayer expense (on condition that they cannot return).

Leave a Comment